Thatcherism, Power, and Alan Moore: The 80s Superhero Zeitgeist

cc81364abbf4027854e3295f10d7abdee8c9a941308cfbf041b86420de257094

Any serious look at the recent history of comics is incomplete without mention of the British Invasion of American comics in the 1980s. At the center of that invasion, of course, was the eccentric genius behind Watchmen, V for Vendetta, Marvelman (or, if you’re snooty about copyright law, Miracleman) and a seminal run on Swamp Thing, to name only a few.

Alan Moore’s work is magical, a designation the writer himself might take literally. A comics historian could write volumes on the ways in which the wildcard warlock reshaped comics, but for my money it was the vivid sociopolitical messages of his books that elevated them (or, at least, most of them) above the other high-quality work being published at the time and made an everlasting impression on the industry. For that we can thank his muse-cum-villain, British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher.

To set the scene, one must understand how Thatcherism typified the political landscape of the 1980s. Roughly cognate with the ruling principles of Reaganism in the United States, Thatcherism is defined primarily by the core principles of economic deregulation, low taxation, and high interest rates (a policy that counteracted inflation in the short term but wound up costing her a large portion of her lower- and middle-class supporters). A more thorough analysis is given in this brief video from the BBC.

These policies, inspired by the work of Friedrich Hayek (author of The Road to Serfdom and a personal idol of Thatcher’s) and the entire Chicago school of economics, appealed with great success to a populace bombarded by the apocalyptic tones of Red Scare propaganda and the anti-socialist sentiment of the 1980’s. In practice, however, the economic policies of the Thatcher government put people out of jobs, greatly widened the income gap, and the botched handling of interest rates made it less preferable for the working class to opt for loans, a situation made even worse by the Iron Lady’s disdain for labor unions.

Still, her rhetoric about small government, her anti-Soviet fearmongering, and her wholehearted embrace of post-Keynesian economic principles made her a guiding light of right-wing neoliberalism. Little wonder she found a kindred spirit in Ronald Reagan, a partnership Moore himself defined as “the Reagan-Thatcher fuck-buddy coalition”. The cesspool of pro-corporatist policies on both sides of the pond led to immense antipathy from the artistic ranks, but this antipathy was nowhere more apparent and forceful than in Britain.

Larkhill_Resettlement_Camp_001This was compounded by the fact that, whilst espousing small government in the name of individualism, the Conservative Party were busy instituting social policies that undermined minority rights—most prominently Section 28, a law curtailing civil liberties for homosexuals, eerily mirrored today by the treatment of the LGBTQ community in modern day Russia under Putin. Another absurdly draconian proposal called for internment camps for AIDS sufferers. Both western world leaders inflected their rhetoric and their concrete policies with echoes of McCarthyism, rampant unchecked corporatism, and the annihilation of civil liberties in the name of fear.

Political zeitgeist often becomes fodder for an artistic revolution, and this was clearly true of comics’ British Invasion, a more radical, openly political movement than its moptop-filled pop music counterpart of the 1960s. A wide gap between popular sentiment and government policy leaves artists with ample room for exploration and morality plays.

I must concede that I am by no means the first to link this massive creative development to Thatcherism. In fact, the idea is popular enough to have boomeranged its way from public consciousness all the way back into comics as a meta-reference in issue 7 of Warren Ellis’s meta-exploratory fiction series Planetary. In an extended homage to exemplary British stories produced in the 80s, Ellis proclaimed (through the character Jakita Wagner), “England was a scary place. No wonder it produced a scary culture.”

warr7Why did this frightening culture inform Moore’s politics in particular? While both were born in Northamptonshire to working-class families, Moore and Thatcher could not be further apart by any other measure. Philosophically, Moore is an anarchist while Thatcher was a free-market conservative, the political equivalent of cats and dogs.

The most obvious attack on establishment fearmongering and nanny-state mass surveillance came in V for Vendetta, a graphic tale of anarchy versus totalitarianism originally serialized in the pages of Warrior from 1982 to 1985, and later completed at DC Comics in 1988. Marvelman, a serial begun the same year as V, gave Moore the opportunity to strike at the heart of an unexplored facet of the superhero mythology. Stories ran the gamut of topics from unchecked power and collateral damage, and played with the genre’s uncomfortable overtones of fascism and eugenics.

Both of these books would set up a recurring theme for most of Moore’s 1980s work: the concentration of power in the hands of a few, whether the government, corporate plutocrats, or a single “superhero,” spelling disaster for the populace.

In V for Vendetta and Marvelman one can see Moore’s political slant most vividly. The former is a story of an anarchist freedom fighter (or, if you prefer, “terrorist”) rebelling against a tyrannical government, and the latter is about a protagonist who finds himself instituting one of his own. Though not bound by a shared universe, the thematic parallels between these books start from opposing sides but reach similar conclusions about the dialectical relationship between freedom and security, and what we give up in search of a pure, absolutist vision of either.

About Rawal Ahmed (9 Articles)
Rawal Ahmed is a freelance writer with an interest in politics, music comic books and technology. More of his work is available at https://posttruthpoliticswatch.wordpress.com

3 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. “Why Did They Have to Get so Political?”: Dissecting A Common Complaint | Black Ship Books
  2. Political Allegories, Serendipity or Prophecy? | Black Ship Books
  3. Zack Snyder’s Watchmen and the Authoritarian Aesthetic | Black Ship Books

Leave a Reply